How Prices, Risks, and Responsibility Differ
In the art and antiques market, the sale of an object may take place through different channels. The two most commonly compared are the auction market and private sale. Although both lead to a transaction, they differ in the way prices are formed, the level of risk involved, the responsibility of the parties, and the impact on the object’s future history.
Understanding these differences is essential for making informed decisions about selling.
What Characterizes the Auction Market?
Auction sales are based on public bidding, where the price is created through competition between participants. The auction house acts as an intermediary, organizer, and guarantor of the procedure.
Key characteristics of the auction market include:
the price reflecting current demand at a specific moment,
the transaction being public and recorded,
the object acquiring a permanent market record (auction result),
the sale being subject to commissions,
the risk that the object may remain unsold.
An auction result does not always reflect the “true” value of an object — it is a record of a particular market situation.
Hammer Price vs. Final Price
One of the most common misunderstandings is equating the hammer price with the amount received by the seller.
In practice:
the buyer pays the hammer price plus a buyer’s premium,
the seller receives an amount reduced by the seller’s commission,
the difference may amount to several tens of percent.
For this reason, auction results should always be analyzed in the context of contractual terms, not solely on the figure published in the catalogue.
Risks of the Auction Market
The auction market involves specific risks:
lack of interest on the day of the auction,
sale below expectations,
permanent recording of a low result in the market history,
difficulty in reselling an object after an unsuccessful auction.
An object that “fails” at auction often loses attractiveness in the short term.
What Is a Private Sale?
A private sale takes place outside public bidding, usually through negotiations between the parties, often with the involvement of an advisor, dealer, or intermediary.
Its characteristics include:
confidentiality of the transaction,
no public price record,
greater control over sale conditions,
time flexibility,
the ability to selectively choose the buyer.
A private sale does not create an official auction record, which in many cases works to the object’s advantage.
Pricing in Private Sales
In a private sale, the price:
is not formed through bidding,
results from negotiation and context,
may be higher or lower than a potential auction result.
This channel is often more suitable for objects that:
have high value,
require discretion,
have uncertain attribution,
are aimed at a narrow group of collectors.
Responsibility and Guarantees
On the auction market, the responsibility of the auction house is usually strictly defined by regulations and limited in time.
In private sales:
the scope of responsibility is determined individually,
expert opinions and documentation play a greater role,
the credibility of the intermediary or advisor is crucial.
Each sales model requires different formal preparation.
Which Channel Should Be Chosen?
There is no universal model of sale. The choice should depend on:
the type of object,
its market history,
the degree of confirmed authenticity,
the purpose of the sale,
the owner’s tolerance for risk.
An auction offers transparency and visibility but involves risk.
A private sale offers control and discretion but requires time and expertise.
Conclusion
The auction market and private sale are two different mechanisms operating under different principles.
An auction answers the question: how much the market is willing to pay today, publicly.
A private sale answers the question: how much can be achieved under the right conditions and over time.
A conscious choice of the sales channel is one of the key elements in protecting the value of a work of art or an antique.
ArtRate.art
